Manslaughter

Manslaughter Defense Attorney in Stuart, FL

Former Law Enforcement & Prosecutorial Experience on Your Side

A manslaughter charge doesn’t require prosecutors to prove premeditation, but it still carries consequences that can reshape the rest of your life. What it does require is proof of how a death occurred, who caused it, and whether any lawful justification existed. Those questions live and die in the evidence, and that’s where our team is built to work. Attorney Adam Less spent years as a law enforcement officer before joining the bar, giving him firsthand knowledge of how evidence is collected and where collection breaks down. Attorney Molly McCaffrey served as an assistant state attorney for the 19th Judicial Circuit beginning in August 2019, prosecuting the same category of serious felonies she now defends against.

ADL Law, P.A. is recognized by Avvo’s Client’s Choice Award and the American Institute of Criminal Law Attorneys, including a 2018 Top 10 Lawyer for Client Satisfaction award. Those credentials reflect what we actually do: review cases thoroughly, challenge the state’s evidence at every turn, and pursue every available defense.

If you or someone you care about is facing a manslaughter charge in Stuart or Martin County, contact us today for a free initial consultation. We offer both office and virtual meetings. Call (772) 280-5052 now.

How Florida Law Defines Manslaughter

Under Florida Statute 782.07, manslaughter is the killing of another person by act, procurement, or culpable negligence (grossly reckless conduct that a reasonable person would know creates a serious risk of harm) without lawful justification, in cases that don’t qualify as excusable homicide or murder. Unlike first-degree or second-degree murder, manslaughter doesn’t require premeditation or a depraved mind. That distinction matters, but it doesn’t make the charge minor.

Standard manslaughter is a second-degree felony, carrying potential penalties of up to 15 years in prison, 15 years of probation, and a $10,000 fine. The charge can be elevated significantly depending on the circumstances:

Firearm or Weapon Use
If a weapon or firearm was involved, the charge is reclassified to a first-degree felony, potentially exposing a defendant to up to 30 years in prison.

Aggravated Manslaughter
When the victim is an elderly or disabled adult, a child under 18, or certain first responders performing their duties, the charge becomes aggravated manslaughter, also a first-degree felony with the same potential 30-year exposure.

These penalty ranges reflect what the law permits, not a guaranteed outcome in any particular case. How charges are ultimately resolved depends on the specific facts, the evidence, and the defense strategy.

Defending Manslaughter Cases at the Martin County Courthouse

Manslaughter charges in Martin County are heard at the Martin County Courthouse in Stuart under Florida’s 19th Judicial Circuit, which also covers Indian River, Okeechobee, and St. Lucie counties. Molly McCaffrey’s prosecutorial experience was in this exact circuit. She knows how these cases are built from the state’s side, which shapes how we take them apart.

We review police reports and evidence collection methods for procedural errors and file pre-trial motions to suppress evidence obtained illegally. What law enforcement did before charges were filed often determines what the state can use at trial.

Talk to a Manslaughter Defense Attorney Before You Say Anything Else

We offer a free initial consultation with no obligation. Meetings are available in our Stuart office or virtually, and we offer payment plans as well as discounts for veterans and law enforcement. The earlier you get counsel involved, the more options can remain open.

Call (772) 280-5052 to speak with ADL Law, P.A. about your manslaughter case today.

Types of Manslaughter Charges in Florida

Florida manslaughter law covers several distinct theories of liability, and the type charged affects both the defense strategy and the potential penalties.

Manslaughter by Act or Procurement

This form involves an intentional act that causes death, one that is neither excusable nor legally justified. Prosecutors often frame these cases as killings that occurred in the heat of passion following sudden provocation. The act itself was deliberate; the charge turns on whether it was lawful. Defenses frequently center on self-defense, the circumstances that triggered the confrontation, and whether any justification applies.

Manslaughter by Culpable Negligence

Culpable negligence doesn’t involve intent to kill. It involves grossly reckless or negligent conduct so severe that a reasonable person would recognize it as creating a substantial risk of serious harm or death. These cases often arise from accidents, but prosecutors argue the defendant’s behavior crossed well past ordinary carelessness. The defense must scrutinize exactly what the defendant did, what they knew, and whether that conduct truly meets the legal threshold.

Vehicular & DUI Manslaughter

When a death results from reckless operation of a motor vehicle or from driving under the influence, Florida prosecutors charge those offenses under separate statutes from standard manslaughter. DUI manslaughter and vehicular manslaughter carry their own penalty structures and procedural considerations. We handle these cases as well.

What the State Must Prove & How We Challenge It

To secure a manslaughter conviction, Florida’s Standard Jury Instructions require the state to prove two elements beyond a reasonable doubt: that the victim is dead and that the death was caused by the defendant’s intentional act, procurement, or culpable negligence. A defendant can’t be found guilty, however, if the killing was legally justifiable or constitutes excusable homicide. Each element is a potential defense target.

Available defenses include:

Self-Defense Under Stand Your Ground
Florida’s Stand Your Ground law can provide immunity from prosecution when a person reasonably believed force was necessary to prevent death or serious bodily harm. If this defense applies, it can stop the case before trial.

Excusable Homicide
Florida law recognizes excusable homicide when a death results from an accident during a lawful act performed with ordinary care. If the state can’t show the defendant acted outside normal conduct, this defense can remove criminal liability.

Justifiable Homicide
A killing is justifiable when it occurs in legitimate defense of self or others against an imminent threat. This overlaps with Stand Your Ground but applies to a broader set of circumstances.

Evidence Challenges
Adam Less’s law enforcement background informs how we scrutinize the state’s evidence. We examine how police conducted the investigation, whether collection procedures followed proper protocol, and whether a pre-trial suppression motion could limit what the prosecution can present at trial. Improperly gathered evidence has no place in the courtroom, and we pursue suppression aggressively when the facts support it.

Continue Reading Read Less

Start the Conversation Today

First Name
Please enter your first name.
Last Name
Please enter your last name.
Phone
Please enter your phone number.

This isn't a valid phone number.
Email
Please enter your email address.

This isn't a valid email address.
Are you a new client?
Please make a selection.
How can we help you?
Please enter a message.
By submitting, you agree to receive text messages from ADL Law, P.A. at the number provided, including those related to your inquiry, follow-ups, and review requests, via automated technology. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Msg & data rates may apply. Msg frequency may vary. Reply STOP to cancel or HELP for assistance. Acceptable Use Policy

Feedback From Those We’ve Represented

Real Stories from Individuals and Families We’ve Helped

“Outstanding Service”
“If you are looking for a defense attorney who will go above and beyond for you, Adam is the one to trust. I am incredibly grateful for his hard work and highly recommend him to anyone in need of legal representation.”

- Alisha D.
“Would Highly Recommend Him”
“After speaking with several law offices, Adam stood out as the only one who demonstrated a deep understanding of the legal system and a determination to ensure we received fair justice.”

- Latoya D.
“Best Ever!”
“I highly recommend to anyone looking for someone great that you can trust to get the job done!”

- Katie F.
“Professional and Knowledgeable”
“If you're looking for a thoughtful, respected, results-driven attorney who truly cares about his clients, Adam Less is the one to call.”

- Ronald M.
“The Right Choice”
“ADL Law was very helpful in resolving my case. Mr. Less discussed my options and was very thorough.”

- Peter C.
“Highly Recommend!”
“Adam is an outstanding attorney. He and his team were professional, responsive, and genuinely cared about helping me through a situation where I needed someone I could rely on and trust.”

- Mark A.
“Exceeded All Expectations!”
“Their outstanding service has left a lasting impression, and I intend to continue utilizing their services for any future needs. I highly recommend their firm.”

- Kristin D.
“An Outstanding Choice”
“What impressed me most was his attention to detail, responsiveness, and genuine care for achieving the best possible outcome.”

- Matthew S.

View All Reviews